What are the challenges facing UK Trade Unions

Title: What are the chief challenges confronting today’s trade brotherhoods in the UK and critically measure the stairss in which they are reacting.


Trade brotherhoods are one of the biggest organisations around the universe today. They have continuously evolved through the ages brought approximately by the invariably altering political and economic clime. They exist to chiefly back up labor-related causes but vary on their set of activities and aims. Some trade brotherhoods would desire to guarantee the proviso of benefits to its members ; others for dickering power and some are strictly for political activities. It can be said that there is diverseness in the signifiers of trade brotherhoods around the Earth and although they may confront the same set of challenges, they are still really much influenced by their immediate environment. They respond consequently to specific challenges by different agencies.

At the start of the 18Thursdaycentury, Britain had one of the strongest and largest trade brotherhoods in Europe. By the bend of the 20Thursdaycentury, these trade brotherhoods began to consolidate their political ( through the labour party ) and industrial influence. However, it wasn’t able to prolong much and bit by bit lost steam due a figure of factor in their immediate environments.

There was a steep dip and a minimum rise in brotherhood ranks around the universe. This is partially due to a figure of contributable factors. The differing values and educational background that people bring with them to work frequently challenges the traditional individualities of brotherhoods and their supposed signifier of corporate actions. Emerging policies of public, and sometimes, private administrations frequently sought to alter the relationship between the employee and the employer into a more distinguishable and individualized construction when one of the intents of the being of trade brotherhoods is merely on the ordinance of employer and employee dealingss. The sense and intent of a brotherhood is get downing to be questioned by a great bulk. This has sometimes undermined the corporate power of brotherhood members and trade brotherhoods in general.

Different trade brotherhoods have different environments, doctrine, constructions, and civilization. They have developed into many signifiers influenced by political orientations and authoritiess. In Europe, Trade brotherhoods are affiliated with political parties. European workers have sought to accomplish economic advantage and political freedom by coincident trade brotherhood and political action ( Miernyk, p. 125 ) . [ 1 ]

Trade Unions in the United Kingdom

Trade brotherhoods in the United Kingdom are no different from trade brotherhoods in the Americas and the remainder of Europe. They besides face challenges related to the keeping of their ranks and their sense or intent.

The Trade Union Congress ( TUC ) is the umbrella organisation of most trade brotherhoods in the UK approximately stand foring six and a half million worker. [ 2 ] Not all trade brotherhoods are members of TUC though. Small organisations like specialist staffs and big organisations like the Police Federation are non members of TUC.

One of the basic functions of brotherhoods is to see to it that its members are protected from the transmutation of wellness services from a philosophical administration to a commercial administration where competition among private houses is going a day-to-day portion of the wellness attention system. An illustration of this is in the National Health Service ( NHS ) where cost film editing steps have resulted to occupation losingss and closings of different infirmary trusts ( Unison, 2007 ) . [ 3 ] Spearheading this motion is Unison. It is the largest brotherhood in the UK with approximately 1.3 million members countrywide. It has a manner of acquiring its messages and concerns across the politicians in the state through political lobbying. [ 4 ]

Challenges of UK Trade Unions

Unions have to postulate with so much alteration in the last two decennaries. International economic restructuring and the relentless demand to be flexible on labour policies and patterns have upset the traditional manners of brotherhood action ( Levesque & A ; Murray ) . [ 5 ] This has virtually weakened the ability of brotherhoods to support its members against different forces in the planetary environment.

Some people think of brotherhoods as weak and unable to do important alterations in the workplace. Some members have small committedness to the ends and aspirations of their brotherhoods. They deal with their brotherhoods merely like what they do in business-they pay their dues and expect something in return in their ‘investment’ subsequently on. In other words, their ‘participation’ is limited to carry throughing their pecuniary and other concern duties. This is evidenced by low elector turnouts in internal meetings, attending at meetings, or the reading of newssheets ( Gall ) . [ 6 ]

There was a really steep diminution in brotherhood rank in the UK by 1997, British trade brotherhood rank had fallen to about 7.1 million members and most of these losingss were from the populace sector. This tendency stopped in 1999 and by 2000, trade unionism was accommodating to the alterations in forms of employment and in order to appeal to immature and portion clip workers most of who are female ( 2007 ) . [ 7 ] This new attack might hold been brought about by the decreasing mean age of new workers and the increasing function of adult females in the corporate universe. In the succeeding old ages, there was a minimum addition in the figure of trade brotherhood ranks of around 27,000 people or 0.4 % ( Palmeret Al, 2004 ) . [ 8 ] This rise and autumn of brotherhood rank as a whole does non reflect similar rises and falls for each national brotherhood. Alternatively, the overall form is a complex of divergent tendencies, the net consequence of a assortment of motions. Even during the sharpest diminutions in entire brotherhood rank, some brotherhoods will spread out and turn ( Esten, p. 10 ) . [ 9 ]

A figure of these rank diminutions were largely due to the diminution of extremely nonionized fabrication industries and the prostration of working category assurance ( Prior, 2000 ) . [ 10 ] As a consequence of the continued diminution of brotherhood ranks in Britain, there has been monolithic restructuring of the trade brotherhoods through amalgamations so that resources can be maximized and they could deduce economic value from it. Harmonizing to Waddington ( 2006 ) , a figure of brotherhood members left because they were dissatisfied with some facets of brotherhood organisation. One of the pressing issues with respects to the diminution in brotherhood rank was the ability of brotherhoods to contend jointly for their members’ wage and working conditions. Some even complained that brotherhoods did non make plenty on wellness and safety ( Waddington, 2006 ) when it is one of the most cardinal issues that workers expect brotherhoods to turn to. [ 11 ]

Trade brotherhoods faced major challenges during the Conservative footings of Margaret Thatcher and John Major because they were frequently viewed as interfering excessively much on Britain’s free market economic system. As a affair of fact, Drinkwater and Ingram ( 2005 ) , cites the diminishing ranks in trade brotherhoods as one of the causes in the diminution of work arrests. [ 12 ] This had Lent much support to the impression that trade brotherhoods have mostly been instrumental in changing the balance in the workplace and doing it hard for concern to travel frontward. The low degrees of work stoppage activities have besides suggested an betterment in workplace industrial relati

Between 1980 and 1993, there were statute laws which weakened trade brotherhoods. There were steps that made it focused on cut downing trade brotherhood powers and do the labor market more flexible. There was the Trade Union Act of 1984 which specified term bounds of brotherhood officers and the usage of secret ballots before work stoppages ( MSN Encarta – Trade Union Movement in Britain ) . The Trade Union Reform Act of 1993 gave workers more rights to do picks in brotherhood ranks and their parts. It was prohibited to necessitate new employees to hold to go members of brotherhoods. The eroding of most brotherhood powers has besides indirectly contributed to the lifting tendency in pay inequality and their possible differences ( Taylor, 2006 ) . [ 13 ]

How are these challenges addressed?

It is clear that the challenges of today’s trade brotherhoods in Britain are to be able to subscribe up and enroll new members and how to acquire them traveling and working in the existent sense of brotherhood work.

Unions adopted a scope of tactics in order to enroll members For illustration, the information airing and enlisting of new members is being made possible through the Internet. Most brotherhoods in the UK have established web sites for them to easy circulate information to members and even to possible members. These besides included the enlargement of benefits and services, the production of cusps, and in some instances, the employment of dedicated recruiters.

Increasing rank in brotherhoods has its large advantages. Of class size ( or figure ) does affair and it practically determines the clout that these brotherhoods could hold within the national and local labour scene. However, being large does non ever connote being great. In the instance of Unison for illustration, it has to run hard for new recruits since it will assist the brotherhood addition more influence and more bargaining power to press in front with their docket. Some of these are in bettering public services, cut downing or even halting favoritism in the workplace, and for better wage and status for members’ services ( 2006 ) . [ 14 ]

Many trade brotherhoods in Britain have late introduced bundles of fiscal services which include discounted insurance and mortgage strategies, brotherhood recognition cards, and vacation price reductions similar to the Union Privilege Benefits Program introduced as portion of the scheme to better brotherhood services to its members ( Waddington, 2006 ) . But brotherhood dockets sometimes differ among brotherhoods particularly their leaders. Harmonizing to Miernyk ( 1962, p.127 ) , the European labour leader is frequently a political group. He can be unrelenting on his onslaughts on the political system while being conservative at times on his demands for pay betterments and other periphery benefits, experiencing that inordinate demands might damage secondary manufacturers.

Unions are in a much better place than decennaries ago due to a figure of reforms and alteration schemes. New Torahs gave better protection to brotherhoods. Benefits were better communicated. As a consequence, ranks have stopped falling.

Information airing and instruction is important. Union members must be able to understand that their rank in brotherhoods is non merely for confidence intents but their active engagement is important in guaranting that the union’s ends are met and sustained. The Trade Union Congress ( TUC ) , which is spearheading a batch of plans, has the “Organising Academy” . This academy helps brotherhoods mount new enlisting and organizing runs. [ 15 ] However, this is non plenty to maneuver the trade unions’ boat to the right way.

There is besides a demand a alteration in the manner brotherhoods are handled and run. More democratic patterns such as the election of brotherhood officers and unfastened treatment of labour issues can promote more engagement.

Stewards may assist in the enlisting procedure but once more, their contacts can be limited. It is of import for brotherhood officers to come and personally pass on with prospective members in order to to the full explicate the pros and cons of brotherhood rank. Exercising organisational rights and duties for the intents of corporate bargaining would itself be a challenge to a well-established system of labour control such as those found in trade unionism. Such challenge is highlighted by the fact that deriving entree to members in order to roll up authorizations and describe them back can be a hard undertaking for most worker organisations due to a batch of physical and economic restraints ( Horn, 2005 ) . [ 16 ]

The bottom line to all of these schemes is the immense cost associated with it. There is a demand for greater fiscal and physical resources. Without it, any move to restructure trade brotherhoods may fall short of outlooks. The effects of such moves may be great. Vibrant and active trade brotherhoods that mark major triumphs in the labour forepart may light involvements in fall ining brotherhoods. An addition in the figure of new members may intend an addition in funding capablenesss. Converting them to increase their fiscal duties ( from 5 % to approximately 30 % ) is another thing.


There a batch of challenges confronting trade brotherhoods in the UK today. Most of these challenges have been brought about by the altering face of the planetary labor motions. These challenges have highlighted to necessitate for workers to derive back their corporate assurance in their rights and power as members of brotherhoods. There is a demand to prolong these trade brotherhoods through enlisting plans and better organizing schemes.

While there are bold moves to turn to most of these challenges, trade brotherhoods should non depend on much support from their members. Solid support must come from the trade brotherhood members, the authorities and society as a whole. It must be comprehensive, collaborative, and wide in order to happen ‘collective’ ways of motivation, educating, and act uponing workers on the benefits of unionism. Trade brotherhoods are in an environment where alterations could easy spell catastrophe or success for them. The TUC may hold started an instruction plan for brotherhood leaders but their current resources may non ever be capable of prolonging it. The authorities can ever present statute law for workers and brotherhoods but it will ever be limited to that sort of undertaking. On the portion of trade brotherhoods, larning to work together efficaciously through instruction plans and accomplishing little triumphs could be an of import measure to finally constructing and prolonging a trade union’s long term end.

If brotherhoods are to last the challenges of today’s planetary economic and labour tendencies, so they must turn to a scope of issues in the keeping and enlisting of members while at the same clip, seeking out different agencies of forming and advancing the benefits of rank through unfastened and extended instruction plans. As in unionism itself, there besides has to be a corporate response of all those straight involved in this procedure. In unsure times, trade brotherhoods must carefully step the lines and set their precedences in order.



Esten, Marten ( 1976 ) ,The Unions: Structure, Development and Management,Difficult tribunal Brace.

Miernyk, William ( 1962 ) ,Trade Unions in the Age of Affluence,Random House.

Journal Article

Drinkwater, S & A ; Ingram, P ( 2005 ) , Have Industrial Relations in the UK Improved?

‘Building a Strong Union’ , Retrieved: March 16, 2007 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.unison.org.uk/news/

Gall, Gregor, ’Trade Unions in Britain: Challenges and Prospects’ , Retrieved: March 15,

2006 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.redflag.org.uk/frontline/eleven/11unions.html

Horn, P ( 2005 ) , ’New Forms of Collective Bargaining: Adapting to the Informal

Economy and New Forms of Work’ , Labor, Capital & A ; Society, Vol. 38 Issue ? p.208-224. Retrieved: March 16, 2007 from EBSCOHost Database.

Levesque & A ; Murray ( 2006 ) , ’How Do Unions Regenerate? Paths to Union Renewal’ , Labor

Surveies Journal, Vol. 31 Issue 3, p1-13. Retrieved March 15, 2007 from EBSCOHost Database.

Palmer, Tomet Al( July 2004 ) , ‘Trade Union Membership in 2003’ , Employment and

Market Analysis and Research, DTI, retrieved: March 15, 2007 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.dti.gov.uk/files/file11430.pdf

Prior, Peggy ( 2000 ) , ’What they forgot to kill-UK Trade Unions and the Organising

Agenda’ , Retrieved: March 15, 2007 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.commu nist-party.org.uk/articles/2003/february/what % 20they % 20forgot % 20to % 20kill.shtml

Taylor, K ( 2006 ) , ’UK Wage Inequality: An Industry and Regional Perspective’ ,Reappraisal

of Labour Economics & A ; Industrial Relations,Vol. 20 Issue 1, p91-124. Retrieved March 15, 2007 from EBSCOHost Database

Waddington, J ( 2006 ) , ’Why Do Members Leave? The Important of Retention to Trade

Union Growth’ , Labor Studies Journal, Vol. 31 issue 3 p15-38. Retrieved March 15, 2007 from EBSCOHost Database

‘Political Campaigning’ , retrieved: March 16, 2007 from

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.unison.org.uk/politicalcampaigning/

‘Trade Union Movement in Britain’ , Retrieved: March 15, 2007 from

hypertext transfer protocol: //uk.encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_122600521_2/Trade_Union_Movement_in_Britain.html

‘TUC Britain at Work’ , retrieved: March 15, 2007 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.tuc.org.uk/

( 2007 ) ‘Prentis Kicks off weekend of NHS protest’ , Retrieved: March 16, 2007 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.unison.org.uk/activists/

‘TUC – Organising and Recruitment’ , Retrieved: March 15, 2007 from

hypertext transfer protocol: //www.tuc.org.uk/organisation/index.cfm